Summary preview
Chaos, Mistakes, and Luck: The Unseen Forces Shaping History
[Music intro] Hey everyone! In each of our lives, no matter how we live it, there are always two things. First, of course, is hot tea with something tasty and a like on a "Another Story" video. And the second is good old-fashioned chaos. No self-respecting event in human history has ever happened without it. And often, it's chaos, mistakes, or just absurd coincidences that have changed the course of our civilization beyond recognition. So, brew your tea, get comfortable, and get ready. You're about to dive into an obscenely large episode on the role of chaos, mistakes, and coincidences in human history. Recently, we released a video about how ancient Egypt might have survived and what that would have led to. We highly recommend watching it. This episode, however, is about how an entire civilization might have vanished due to one foolish oracle's advice.
From Egypt to Persia: The Lost Trade Empire
To understand what we're talking about, let's look at a map of modern Egypt. Its gem is, of course, the Suez Canal, an artery connecting the Mediterranean and Red Seas. In the 20th century alone, it was fought over in at least two major and four smaller conflicts. And it's no wonder, because the ability to cut 8,000 km off a journey and sail to India without going around Africa is incredibly valuable even today. In the past, this artery essentially turned impossible journeys into possible ones. Because sailing around Africa to India thousands of years ago was physically impossible for people, but cutting through was very much doable. This is what Darius I took advantage of when he created the Pharaohs' Canal. After conquering Egypt around 500 BCE, Darius fulfilled a human dream. Europe began trading with India and China, and it became much easier to transport goods to and from the Middle East. For a long time, due to British and American exceptionalism, Columbus's achievements couldn't be downplayed in official history. Therefore, textbooks rarely and very reluctantly mentioned the existence of sea routes to India and ancient, more developed civilizations. But now, the taboo is lifted. It's widely known, for example, that in Ancient Rome, the demand for silk from India and China was so high that Pliny the Elder called this craze one of the reasons for the empire's economic decline. People would mortgage their homes to buy that coveted fabric and stand out, with money consequently flowing to India – flashbacks to Donald Trump's speeches, right? And Rome traded with India through the very same Pharaohs' Canal. Slightly earlier, Persia did the same, achieving the main 'achievement' that allows merely good civilizations to become great and leave a mark on history. This achievement is called 'international influence,' and any great empire acquired it one way or another. The Greeks traded, wrote poems, and established colonies from Africa to Crimea. The Romans spread influence by fire and sword, and China through culture. But in the vast majority of cases, trade played a decisive role. Persians are remembered as warriors, but thanks to trade, they spread their influence across half the world and have continued to play a significant role since Darius's time. The Phoenicians spread their alphabet through trade, and Britain, Spain, Portugal, and France literally became superpowers by trading with the entire world, during which process the United States of America was suddenly born. Most historians believe that ancient Egypt was ruined by its self-absorption. But Egypt lacked that 'thing' that would have elevated the country to a new level and preserved its civilization in history. It allowed them to exist for thousands of years, but closer to the beginning of our era, surviving without soft power and global influence was impossible. Religion, culture, trade – Egypt didn't invest in any of these branches. This is somewhat understandable for a country
Britain, Celts, and the Lost Silver: Rome's Most Expensive Mistake
The Celts, about whom we also recently released an episode, couldn't achieve this. And, as you might have guessed, there's a mistake involved here too. Not just one, but two! Both happened in the 1st century CE under Emperor Claudius, for the same reason. The first led to the disappearance of the Celtic state, and the second, possibly, to the disappearance of Rome itself. After all, Claudius, who came to power after Caligula in 41 CE, wasn't particularly popular. The solution, as always in the ancient world, was simple: conquer something and earn money. Rome was a bit different from others in that 'earning' meant not just looting, but also extracting resources, creating jobs, and so on. For the Celts, however, this offered little comfort, as Britain was chosen as one of the targets for Roman economic expansion. In 43 CE, the legendary Vespasian, who would later become emperor, landed there. The Celts fought bravely but were crushed. And in July, Claudius personally accepted the surrender of twelve local rulers and rubbed his hands, anticipating a flow of slaves, grain, and, most importantly, silver to Rome. Coins in Rome were more than just money. They bore the emperor's profile. And it's clear that whoever contributed more appeared more often in the markets – native advertising, so to speak. Only, it turned out that Britain was a complete flop. There was silver, but it barely covered the expenses of suppressing various Boudica rebellions and building Hadrian's Wall and other defensive structures. The consensus among historians is that, at best, Britain as a province had a zero balance. Therefore, knowing this, Claudius likely wouldn't have gone there. The Celts had a chance to preserve a great civilization, and who knows, perhaps indigenous Britons could have resisted even before the Norman Conquest. And Rome, on the other hand, gained an asset that, while pleasant, didn't help the empire at all. This leads to the second mistake, which National Geographic magazine calls nothing less than Rome's most expensive mistake. Claudius wasn't just looking for silver in Britain. Work was underway on all the empire's borders. For instance, the Roman historian Tacitus described one episode in his 'Annals.' He tells of a group of legionaries, fed up to their eyeballs, whom a legate forces to search for silver in Germany. According to Tacitus, the legionaries devised a cunning plan: to ask the emperor to honor their commander with accolades, so that he would calm down, give up, and stop demanding they work. For a long time, this anecdote was considered just that – an anecdote. Until in 2016, a 72-year-old former paratrooper, Jürgen Eigenbrod, decided to go boar hunting in the hills around the historic spa town of Bad Ems. His attention was drawn to two straight lines on an abandoned field. Jürgen, apparently, subscribes to 'Another Story' and follows archaeology releases, because the man knew that straight lines don't occur naturally. Archeologists who
The Battle of Midway: A Lottery with a Japanese Accent
Now, let's move closer to modern times. What, for instance, do you know about the Battle of Midway? Honestly, without Googling, most of you would probably mumble something vague about "a one-sided US victory," because Japan was inferior in resources, and you might mention the recent movie, which, of course, embellished everything. But in reality, the Battle of Midway is one of the most tragicomic battles in history. The coincidences and mistakes that changed its course are so numerous that you wouldn't have enough fingers, including your toes, to count them. Literally, any one of them could have changed the outcome of the battle beyond recognition. For example, before the battle, the best commander of the US Pacific Fleet, Admiral Halsey, fell ill. And in violation of all instructions, he left in his place Raymond Spruance – a man who, by the chain of command, shouldn't have been leading the American group at all. Yet, it was he who led the US to victory, including by making another seemingly erroneous decision. At the end of the victorious day, Spruance ordered a halt to the pursuit of the shattered remnants of Admiral Nagumo's carrier strike force. To this day, many textbooks call Spruance a coward. And senior officers in 1942 almost wanted to punch their commander for letting the weakened and un-destroyed Japanese forces go. But it later turned out that powerful battleships of another admiral, Yamamoto, were already on their way to intercept and cover. And if the Americans had continued to pursue the Japanese, they themselves would have fallen into an ambush, and the battle would have ended not in victory, but in a draw. And from a military science perspective, Spruance was indeed mistaken. He had no intelligence, and his decisions were indeed made – whether out of cowardice or by trusting his intuition. But it was precisely this "cowardice" that allowed the US to win. And also – an almost inhuman amount of luck. Prepare to start counting fingers, because a Japanese scout misspoke and said the Americans had no aircraft carriers, leading Admiral Nagumo to underestimate the threat 2 hours before the clash. That's one. Two. The Japanese destroyer 'Arashi,' having gone off course, fell behind the main fleet. It rushed to catch up, and it was only thanks to this accidental 'guide' that the Americans found the main Japanese forces. Three. Japanese submarines, which were supposed to track American movements, made their first navigational error in a year, arriving at the designated location several hours late and missing the US fleet, which in 99 out of 100 cases they would have detected and reported. Four. The US submarine 'Tarpon' attempted to destroy the Japanese aircraft carrier 'Kaga' with torpedoes. In reality, two of the three torpedoes missed, and one failed to detonate. The 'Kaga' was eventually sunk by pilots who were tasked with bombing a different aircraft carrier, the 'Soryu.' Oh, and these pilots weren't supposed to be there at all. They
Netherlands: The Golden Age and the Missed Australia
Let's start with the Netherlands. If you're not aware, this tiny country was once one of the world's superpowers. It all began with the declaration of independence from Spain in 1581. Formally, it continued the ongoing War of Independence, which wouldn't end until 1648. But in fact, for the most part, the war was only on paper, while during this period, the country experienced its Golden Age. The Dutch East India Company became the world's first joint-stock company. In 1669, it was recognized as the richest private firm in history. The East India Company even had a private army, which, for example, successfully expelled the Portuguese from Indonesia. Trade with Japan, China, Ceylon, and Indonesia was effectively monopolized by the Dutch. To say they were respected in Europe would be an understatement. Almost the entire modern financial market is rooted in this country, and in those times, the Dutch created the first stock exchange, a multinational corporation, a system of customs, taxes, and so on, and so forth. It is here, by the way, that the misunderstanding lies, due to which modern Netherlands is called Holland. Holland is the name of the Republic of the United Provinces with its capital in Amsterdam. De facto, it was there that all the processes that made the Netherlands a superpower were managed. The main office of the East India Company was also located there. So, all visitors called the country Holland, without much fuss about details. A prime example is Peter I, who used this word in all his documents. Other rulers were no different. In general, the name of the most developed region was taken as the name of the entire country, which the Netherlands still suffers from. Only in 2020 did the country's official institutions abandon the use of the name "Holland." But we are interested in something else: where did the superpower that was the richest and one of the most influential in the 15th century go? This is, of course, a complex topic, but there is one foolish mistake that helps understand all the processes. In 1606, one of the East India Company's ships, under the command of Willem Janszoon, reached an island he named New Zealand. Willem landed in Australia, becoming the first European to do so. Today, all textbooks name the Briton James Cook as the discoverer of Australia, but he only reached the continent's shores in 1770. The first was the Dutchman Janszoon in 1606. And today, Australians might be speaking Dutch if not for Willem's foolish mistake. The explorer, a financier to the core, declared that the continent would bring no profit. After a brief study of the area, the Dutch were unimpressed. In subsequent years, the question of colonizing Australia was raised a couple of times in the Netherlands, but it went no further than discussions. And then Great Britain reached the continent, colonized it, and began draining its resources, using which it became the leading trading power, defeating the Netherlands. Of course, the country's
Karansebeș: The Battle They Lost Themselves
Let's move on to another mistake that cost the Holy Roman Empire its last vestiges of power. In 1787, another Russo-Turkish war broke out. But unlike previous ones, this one had a twist. The disputes between the two countries did not go unnoticed by Europe, which did not want the Ottoman Empire to lose its power too quickly. Britain, France, and Prussia supported Turkey, but Russia had a trump card – a military alliance with the Holy Roman Empire. It was also nearing its end, but still strong. And the family ties of the Austrian Habsburgs were still felt in all the high houses of Europe. In short, everything looked good. However, in reality, the army of the Holy Roman Empire was a strange spectacle. Gypsies, Germans, Slavs, Italians, Hungarians, and other nationalities spoke different languages, were difficult to manage, and didn't always support the leadership's decisions. This was especially true for the Romanians, who had a decent relationship with the Ottoman Empire. This motley, semi-autonomous army gathered on September 17, 1788, near the town of Karansebeș in modern-day Romania. An anxious anticipation of battle hung in the air. In some places – even too anxious. They failed to surprise Turkey with a swift attack, and according to intelligence, the Ottomans were planning offensive operations on Austrian territory. In short, there was a lot of jitters. One of the commanders constantly sent hussars to the other side of the river to check if the Turks had arrived there. In the evening of that day, the hussars, during a raid, encountered a peasant with barrels of alcohol. According to another version, the hussars were Romanians and deliberately robbed a convoy. According to a third, rumors of a robbed convoy were a fake spread by Turkish saboteurs. The main thing is that the subsequent events are clearly documented. Infantrymen were sent after the missing hussars, and a dispute broke out between the two branches of the army. Again, one version says it was due to drunkenness. The second refers to ethnic conflict, and the third to spies. But the mistake made by one of the participants in the brawl could have cost the entire Holy Roman Empire its life, because this unknown soldier shouted: "Turks!" Perhaps he was trying to distract everyone from the conflict. Perhap
