Summio

Article

Hadot's "Active" Stoic Exercises by Anitra Russell

Exploring the significance of spiritual exercises in Stoicism, as understood by Pierre Hadot, and their connection to Epictetus's three disciplines for achieving inner freedom and wisdom.

16 min read

Available in

Summary preview

Stoic Active Spiritual Exercises: The Path to Self-Improvement

Stoicism, a philosophy born in Ancient Greece, offers not just a collection of theoretical knowledge but a practical guide to living. In today's world, awash with information and distractions, returning to the roots of Stoic wisdom can be the key to finding inner harmony and resilience. The concept of 'active' spiritual exercises, developed by the French philosopher Pierre Hadot, deserves particular attention. These exercises, rooted in the teachings of Epictetus, represent an effective way to transform oneself and approach the ideal of the sage.

Introduction: Philosophy as a Way of Life

Stoicism has always emphasized the importance of autarky – self-sufficiency and inner freedom, a state where an individual depends only on themselves. Pierre Hadot, in his exploration of ancient philosophy, saw this pursuit as a universal ideal present in various philosophical schools. However, as often happens, people tend to fall captive to external circumstances, passions, and desires, distancing themselves from their true selves. The ancient Stoics addressed this problem by turning their philosophy into a daily practice. For them, spiritual exercises were not mere rituals but a way to 'return to oneself,' to free oneself from a state of alienation caused by anxiety, passions, and insatiable desires. The Stoics believed that philosophy is not a subject to be studied but a way of life. As Epictetus wrote, some people merely talk about the 'art of living as a human being' but do not live worthily themselves. Seneca compared this to transforming a true love for wisdom (philosophy) into a love for words (philology). Musonius Rufus warned against 'sophists' who 'swell up with many theories' and against 'corrupt and soft' philosophers whose theories are 'enough to absorb a man's life.' Epictetus also lamented those who do not apply the knowledge gained in practice, contenting themselves with analyzing syllogisms and hypothetical arguments. For the Stoics, philosophy was a training method, enabling one to live differently and view the world from a new perspective. These exercises were designed to strengthen and internalize the intellectual understanding of Stoic precepts so that an individual could face any adversity – from minor irritations to serious calamities – with equanimity. Such equanimity is not born of selfishness but from understanding how difficult it is to help others when one is mired in their own problems. Stoicism builds a strong foundation on the shifting sands of life, allowing for more effective coping with inevitable difficulties. In turn, the strength and stability gained make us more present in the world and better prepared to support loved ones.

Main Theses: The Three Pillars of Stoic Practice

Pierre Hadot identifies several types of spiritual exercises. Among them are morning and evening reflections, where one plans the day ahead or analyzes the past, contemplating adherence to Stoic teachings. There is also premeditatio malorum – the practice of anticipating misfortunes and reflecting on how to face them with strength and dignity, remembering that they are 'indifferent' and not within our control, and thus not evils. However, Hadot places special emphasis on 'active' Stoic exercises, which he calls 'practical exercises designed to form habits.' He briefly mentions three of them: self-mastery, the fulfillment of duty, and indifference to indifferent things. These three types of active exercises, as it turns out, perfectly align with the three areas of practice identified by Epictetus and known in the Stoic tradition as the 'three disciplines.' According to Hadot, Epictetus, 'the greatest authority on Stoicism in the time of Marcus Aurelius,' pointed to three spheres where things 'depend on us,' building on the famous division from the first book of the Enchiridion: 'Some things are within our control, and others are not.' According to Epictetus, 'what is within our control are our judgments, impulses, desires, aversions, in short, whatever is our own doing.' As Hadot writes, 'what is within our control are the actions of our own soul, because we are free to choose them.' Among these soul actions, some are related to the realm of judgment and assent, others to the realm of desire, and finally, others to the realm of impulses to action. Thus, from Hadot's active exercises, self-mastery pertains to the sphere of desires, the fulfillment of duty to the sphere of action, and indifference to indifferent things to the correct use of judgment and assent.

Self-Mastery (Enkrateia)

To achieve self-mastery, according to Hadot, it is necessary to radically reduce one's desires and aspirations, limiting them exclusively to moral virtue – the only thing that 'is within our control.' Similarly, our aversions should be reduced to moral evil. Anything that falls outside these two spheres is beyond our control, and worrying about it is a waste of time. Ancient sources add nuances to the understanding of self-mastery. Diogenes Laërtius describes Zeno of Citium as a model of self-mastery and autarky (self-sufficiency), mentioned earlier. Zeno was known for his 'frugality, contentment with poverty, [and] detachment in social behavior.' An epigram by Zenodotus called Zeno the 'inventor of self-sufficiency' (autarky), who renounced wealth and founded a school that became the 'mother of fearless freedom.' A. A. Long notes that Zeno lived publicly but demonstrated indifference to common markers of success and deep satisfaction with what others might call asceticism. Long writes that enkrateia (self-mastery) is not identical to ataraxia (a state of imperturbability), but nevertheless, 'all three Hellenistic schools postulate the ideal of tranquility, the attainment of which is a necessary condition for rational control over one's desires.' While Zeno's emphasis seemed to be on renouncing material possessions, there are many things in life we might desire that cannot be bought with money. Hadot describes such 'desired things as wealth and health' as not being within our control, and therefore capable of making people excessively unhappy when they are absent from life. Indeed, health can depend on economic status, but even people with the most expensive health insurance get sick, sometimes for no apparent reason. Sometimes I myself desire quiet and peace to read a book. It costs nothing, yet it is a desire to which I am sometimes excessively attached. Another personal example: I wish my child would behave in a certain way, for instance, with respect and deference to a dear mother. Again, this is not a material good, but it is a desire, and it puts me at the mercy of a five-year-old who, while charming in many respects, does not always – or, indeed, ever – prioritize my desires. Instead of working backward and subtracting from the typical, non-Stoic view of what is 'necessary' or simply desirable in life – money, health, status, romantic relationships, a quiet room, an unusually obedient child – we need to discard all of these and start with the absolute essentials, then add to them. Moral virtue is all we should desire if we are to achieve self-mastery. Conversely, moral evil is what we should strive to avoid. Difficult? Yes. Requires superhuman abilities? Likely. Indeed, Long noted that just as modern anthropology views people's interests and needs as 'largely social constructs,' the emphasis of Hellenistic philosophies on asceticism and self-denial was 'an invitation to enter an alternative world and find a new 'self'.' He therefore

Fulfillment of Duty (Kathekonta)

The fulfillment of duty differs from the other two active exercises in that it ultimately depends on other people. It is important to remember the distinction between what is within our control and what is not, and to recognize that in fulfilling our duties to others, we control our moral intention. The outcome of our efforts – how they are received, whether our relationship with the other person improves, whether their future expectations increase – is not within our control. Newcomers to Stoicism are sometimes surprised by the social element of this philosophy, believing it to be about suppressing emotions and withdrawing from the world to minimize suffering. Such an approach, however, would not allow us to live in accordance with our nature, which is that of a rational being who has obligations depending on the role we play: citizen, friend, parent, spouse. As Marcus Aurelius wrote: > 'For we are made for cooperation, like feet, like hands, like eyelids, like the rows of upper and lower teeth. To act against one another is therefore contrary to nature; and to be irritated and to turn away is to act against nature.' Seneca, in turn, states: > 'No school possesses greater kindness and gentleness; none has more love for humanity, or is more devoted to the common good. The goal it sets before us is to be useful, to help others, and to care not only for ourselves but for all as a whole and for each person individually.' Hadot writes: > 'To find a basis for this theory of 'duties,' the Stoics return to their fundamental intuition: the instinctive, primordial agreement of a living being with itself, which expresses nature's deepest will. Living beings have an innate tendency to preserve themselves and to repel what threatens their integrity. When the human mind appears, the natural instinct becomes a reflective, reasoned choice: something is chosen because it corresponds to natural tendencies, such as love for life and children, or love for one's fellow citizens, based on an instinct of sociability.' The three disciplines – desire, action, and assent – intersect, as will be discussed further. Refraining from our own desires or rising above them can be beneficial when fulfilling duties to others. If we are too self-absorbed and focused on getting what we want, it hinders ethical growth. If we spend all our time in the office hoping for a lucrative promotion, we are unlikely to be able to help a friend. If we travel the world ticking items off our wish list, we might miss a call from a sick parent. Enchiridion Quotes for Fulfillment of Duty: 'Remember that you are an actor in a play, which will be such as the author chooses: short, if he wants it short; long, if he wants it long. If he wants you to play the part of a beggar, play it with all your skill; and likewise if you play a cripple, an official, or a private citizen. For it is your business to play the assigned role as well as possible; but to choose the role is another's.' (17) 'Appropriate

Indifference to Indifferent Things

This exercise relies most heavily on our capacity for rationality and is most closely associated with the Stoic topos of logic. Hadot describes logic as 'the mastery of inner discourse.' By carefully observing this inner dialogue, we can see if our logic is flawed and thus leads to emotional disturbances. The essence of this exercise is precisely what Marcus Aurelius described in Meditations 11.16: > 'One soul finds the strength to live a perfectly happy life, if we can remain indifferent to indifferent things.' Hadot describes this as an 'internal' exercise, unlike self-mastery and the fulfillment of duty, which are more externally oriented. It is useful, as we discuss logic and, by extension, wisdom, to consider this practically unattainable yet instructive ideal – the Stoic sage. Hadot quotes the French philosopher Bernard Groethuysen, who emphasizes the sage's relationship to the cosmos: > 'The consciousness he has of the world is something special to the sage. Only the sage keeps the whole picture constantly in mind, never forgets the world, thinks and acts in relation to the cosmos… The sage is part of the world, he is cosmic. He does not allow himself to be distracted from the world or detached from the cosmic whole… The image of the sage and the conception of the world form, so to speak, an inseparable unity.' When you reorient yourself, you realize that the Universe is vast, it is not a 'one-man show,' and it contains an infinite number of moving parts, among which we are to 'matter little' – this is Hadot's clarification of the concept of 'indifferents' in Stoicism. Indifference to indifferent things does not mean emotional closure to anything that might cause pain, and consequently, living a small, isolated life. On the contrary, through the logical analysis of our inner discourse within the context of this vast backdrop, we approach our ideal – the sage, whose life is marked by ataraxia and autarky. Alongside an expanded view of the environment in which we live, indifference to indifferent things fosters a refined focus on the only thing that is not indifferent: our moral intention. Hadot emphasizes that this 'causes people to transform themselves and their attitude toward the world.' There is some overlap between this exercise and self-mastery, as we focus only on what we can control and what matters to achieve greater self-sufficiency. Indifference to indifferent things also pairs well with the fulfillment of duty; as we focus on what we can accomplish in this life, we can turn our gaze to others and see opportunities there to manifest our virtue – and the practice of indifference to indifferent things means we will not be discouraged by the outcome of our attempts to help others. Enchiridion Quotes for Indifference to Indifferent Things: 'Therefore, remove your aversion from everything that is not within our power, and transfer it to what is contrary to nature among those things that are within our power.' (2.2) 'Do not seek for