Summio

Book

Old-age Security in Comparative Perspective

This book dives deep into how different countries handle old-age security, looking at policies, their history, and what really makes them tick.

14 min read

Available in

Summary preview

Unpacking Old-Age Security: A Deep Dive into Global Policies This book offers a comprehensive, comparative, and critical examination of old-age security policies worldwide, moving beyond traditional explanations to propose a new theoretical framework: neo-pluralism. It challenges the prevailing view that pension policies are solely the outcome of class conflict between capital and labor, arguing instead that a multitude of groups, including ethnic, religious, regional, and organized senior advocacy groups ('the grey lobby'), exert significant influence. The authors test this theory through in-depth historical case studies of four industrial nations (United States, United Kingdom, Sweden, Germany) and three developing nations (India, Nigeria, Brazil), followed by a large-scale quantitative analysis of 50 countries (18 industrial, 32 developing). This rigorous methodology allows them to build an evidence-based argument for neo-pluralism and even predict future policy developments, particularly in the U.S. The book highlights the complexity of old-age security, shaped by historical legacies, economic realities, political compromises, and evolving social values, and emphasizes the practical implications of its findings for individuals, policymakers, and researchers. The Big Picture: What's This Book All About? The book's primary objective is to dissect global old-age security policies, examining their structure and underlying philosophies. It critically assesses whether these systems are fair, effective, and truly provide the promised security. To achieve this, the authors test five different theories of policy formation. Their research encompasses four developed industrial nations (United States, United Kingdom, Sweden, Germany) and three developing nations (India, Nigeria, Brazil), underscoring that old-age security is a universal concern with diverse solutions. Challenging the Old Guard: A New Way of Thinking The authors challenge the traditional 'class conflict' theory, which posits that social welfare policies like pensions are primarily a result of struggles between labor and capital. They propose 'neo-pluralism' as a more accurate framework. Neo-pluralism suggests that policy is shaped by the interplay of numerous diverse groups, not just two opposing economic forces. These influential groups include ethnic communities, religious organizations, regional blocs, and, crucially, 'the grey lobby' – organized groups of older adults advocating for their interests. The book argues that these groups often wield more influence on old-age security policy than purely class-based organizations, shifting the focus from economic class to a complex mix of identity, interest, and organization. Testing the Theories: From Case Studies to Big Data The authors validate their neo-pluralist theory through a dual methodological approach. First, they conduct detailed historical case studies in the seven selected countries, analyzing policy debates, lobbying efforts,